I agree. It's hard to create self sustaining community options. Maybe @Oregon_Puppy is right that my content is too complicated. The Hall of Champions, Alliance Bank, and Wanted thread, and 1st ARF met with initial interest, but never really got going.
Some good things have come along. It seems that round robin tournaments have worked out well. Posting victory screenshots seems to be the best way to get prestige in battle. Creating and joining clans is fun, but usually doesn't amount to anything. With the new tactics category there should be something new to do. But this seems to be the extent of the community.
We need to come up with something accessable to all players: new and old. Maybe a month long team battle? Have two teams that players are assigned to fairly. Keep track of victories with screenshots and see who wins in the end.
Idk if that will work. Maybe it would be more fun to do something that didn't rely on screenshots or gameplay.